- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
The following math problem, which appeared on a Scottish maths paper, has been making the internet rounds.
The first two parts require students to interpret the meaning of the components of the formula T(x)=5√36+x2+4(20−x), and the final "challenge" component involves finding the minimum of T(x) over 0≤x≤20. Usually this would require a differentiation, but if you know Snell's law you can write down the solution almost immediately. People normally think of Snell's law in the context of light and optics, but it's really a statement about least time across media permitting different velocities.
One way to phrase Snell's law is that least travel time is achieved when sinθ1sinθ2=v1v2, where θ1,θ2 are the angles to the normal and v1,v2 are the travel velocities in the two media.
In our puzzle the crocodile has an implied travel velocity of 1/5 in the water and 1/4 on land. Furthermore, the crocodile travels along the riverbank once it hits land, so θ2=90∘ and sinθ2=1. Snell's law now says that the path of least time satisfies sinθ1=x√36+x2=45, giving us 25x2=16x2+242. Solving, 32x2=242,x2=82 and the solution is x=8.
The first two parts require students to interpret the meaning of the components of the formula T(x)=5√36+x2+4(20−x), and the final "challenge" component involves finding the minimum of T(x) over 0≤x≤20. Usually this would require a differentiation, but if you know Snell's law you can write down the solution almost immediately. People normally think of Snell's law in the context of light and optics, but it's really a statement about least time across media permitting different velocities.
One way to phrase Snell's law is that least travel time is achieved when sinθ1sinθ2=v1v2, where θ1,θ2 are the angles to the normal and v1,v2 are the travel velocities in the two media.
In our puzzle the crocodile has an implied travel velocity of 1/5 in the water and 1/4 on land. Furthermore, the crocodile travels along the riverbank once it hits land, so θ2=90∘ and sinθ2=1. Snell's law now says that the path of least time satisfies sinθ1=x√36+x2=45, giving us 25x2=16x2+242. Solving, 32x2=242,x2=82 and the solution is x=8.
Comments
Post a Comment